JR1 - Journal · how to object
The cry and the sentence
Read the passage, then write your journal entry. No bet and no multiple choice today.
Every one of us started life the same way. We cried, and somebody fixed it. Hungry, cold, tired, bored: one loud signal covered everything, and it worked. For a baby, that is not a bad habit. It is the only tool available.
The trouble is that the tool stops working, and nobody announces the day it expires. A sigh, an eye roll, a groan, a “this is so unfair” before the test has even been passed out: these are the grown-up versions of the cry. They send one message, I am unhappy, so change this, and they ask the other person to guess the rest.
Researchers who study this have found three things.
- Pressure teaches people to resist you. When displeasure is used as force, the other person either gives in and resents it or digs in. Either way, you have spent some of the relationship.
- Naming a feeling shrinks it. Putting a feeling into words lowers its intensity in the brain. “I’m worried about this test” calms you down, and a groan does not.
- Self-control predicts outcomes. A study that followed about a thousand children into adulthood found that early self-control predicted health, income, and staying out of trouble, even after accounting for intelligence.
Compare two students who feel exactly the same way:
Two students who feel exactly the same way.
| The cry | The sentence | |
|---|---|---|
| What it sounds like | “This is ridiculous. We never learned this.” | “I’m nervous about this. Can you tell us what it covers?” |
| What the listener hears | An attack | A question |
| What can happen next | Nothing, or a fight | An answer |
| What it costs | Goodwill, time, energy | Ten seconds |
Notice what this does not say. It does not say hide your feelings or never object. If something is unfair, say so. Say it in a sentence, to the person who can do something about it, after you know the facts.
Journal
Describe a time someone’s displeasure was aimed at you before they knew the whole story. What did it make you want to do?
Write five or more sentences. No names.
On the form: enter the code, then write your journal entry in Question 1. Skip everything else.